Bay Isle
Bay Isle: Local Questions Answered
Where is Bay Isle in Winter Garden?
Bay Isle is off Winter Garden Vineland Road at Bristol Isle Lane, on Hampshire Bay Circle, Tabago Bay Drive and St Lucia Isle Court, beside Black Lake. The plat also touches Fowler Grove Boulevard and New Stone Crest Boulevard. It is inside City of Winter Garden limits.
What types of homes are in Bay Isle?
Bay Isle has 91 single-family homes built from 2002 to 2006, according to Orange County Property Appraiser records. Homes range from about 2,200 to 5,340 square feet on lots of about 0.28 acre and up; 77 are two-story and 14 are one-story. Thirteen homes border Black Lake. There are no townhomes.
How much do homes cost in Bay Isle?
Over the past two years (MLS data, October 2026), homes in Bay Isle sold four times for a median of about $843,000, ranging from about $780,000 to $1.1 million. For today's listings, see the top of this page.
What are the HOA fees in Bay Isle?
Recent MLS listings show HOA dues of about $141 to $158 per month as of October 2026. Orange County property records and Florida's official list of special districts don't show a community development district (CDD) for Bay Isle, but check the property tax bill for any special assessments. The association is Bay Isle at Black Lake Homeowners' Association, Inc.
What schools serve Bay Isle?
Orange County Public Schools' 2026-27 school zones place Bay Isle in SunRidge Elementary, SunRidge Middle and West Orange High School.
Zoning can change and varies by street, so confirm a specific address with Orange County Public Schools' Find My School tool, and compare school grades in the Florida School Accountability Reports.
Does Bay Isle have homes on Black Lake, and is it gated?
Yes. Orange County GIS shows 13 Bay Isle homes bordering Black Lake, on Hampshire Bay Circle and St Lucia Isle Court, and the association owns a lakefront tract. Realtor sites describe Bay Isle as gated with a community pier. Black Lake Park and Black Lake Preserve are separate communities on the same lake.
Can you rent homes in Bay Isle short term?
No Bay Isle-specific rental rules turned up in our research. HOA documents often limit leasing, so confirm the current rules with the association before buying if you plan to rent.
